A definition
Zero average is not no movement
What can we measure when left and right cancel?
The 2 printed paragraphs this passage explains
- §4, paragraph 9: The displacements in any time t are distributed like random errors; what matters is how the constant in the exponent depends on D, and it gives the root of the mean square displacement along X, λx, as the square root of 2Dt.
- §4, paragraph 10: The mean displacement therefore grows as the square root of the time, and the root mean square of the total displacement in space is λx times the square root of 3.
Left and right can cancel in the average while every tracer moves. Squaring before averaging keeps track of the spread.
A signed mean answers where the ensemble’s centre has moved. It does not answer how far its members have wandered. For a centred distribution, rightward and leftward contributions balance even while the distribution broadens.
The model’s mean displacement can be zero while its mean-square displacement is positive.
To retain the movement, square each displacement before averaging. Taking the square root of that mean square returns a length: the root-mean-square displacement, or RMS. A mean absolute displacement is a different observable, and neither is the length of a wandering trajectory.
Show every step here: Zero average is not no movement
- Put every tracer’s starting point at zero and measure along one line, the -axis, with right as positive and left as negative. After the same observation time, each tracer’s displacement is a signed number: where it is now minus where it started.
- The angle brackets stand for an average over the whole ensemble of tracers the model describes: is the average of the signed displacement, and is the average of its square, the mean square.
- Take four displacements, in micrometres: −3, −1, +1, +3. As many went left as right, and by the same amounts, so they stand in for a centred distribution.
- Their sum is (−3) + (−1) + (+1) + (+3) = 0: the two leftward numbers cancel the two rightward ones. Divide by four: the signed mean is zero.
- The signed mean says where the centre of the group has moved, and here it has not moved at all. It says nothing about how far the members have spread out from that centre.
- Square each displacement first. A negative number times itself is positive, so the squares are 9, 1, 1, 9 square micrometres, and now nothing can cancel.
- The squares add to 20. Divide by four: the mean square is 5 square micrometres. It is positive although the signed mean was zero, which is the statement of the formula:
The model’s mean displacement can be zero while its mean-square displacement is positive.
- In the formula both averages belong to the model, over its whole ensemble. Four numbers drawn at random from such a model would give a signed mean near zero rather than exactly zero; these four were chosen to cancel exactly, so that the arithmetic stays easy to follow.
- The mean square is measured in square micrometres, an area, not a length. To return to a length, take the square root: is approximately 2.236, so the root-mean-square displacement, or RMS, is about 2.236 micrometres.
- The mean distance, ignoring direction, is a third average: (3 + 1 + 1 + 3) / 4 = 2 micrometres, the mean absolute displacement. RMS and mean distance weigh the large displacements differently, so 2.236 and 2 answer different questions. They are not inconsistent answers.
- Neither average is the length of the path a tracer wandered along. A tracer that moves 2 micrometres right and then 1 micrometre left ends 1 micrometre from its start, having travelled 3. The squares record where the tracers ended up, not how far they walked on the way.
Explore the equations in this step
Read each operation, check its units and assumptions, or open the mathematical step behind it. These are modern teaching equations, not the equations as printed.
Explore the equation · Modern model notation
Why the apparent speed depends on how you watch
Shown in modern letters; Einstein's are in §4 of the German source face.
divides
Select a term or operation. In the formula, Down enters an operation, Up returns to its parent, and Left/Right move between siblings. Escape clears selection. Tab leaves the formula.
Each term and operation, in words
No live values
Symbolic here. Open the linked laboratory for a worked example and live values.
Read the equation aloud in words
Apparent coordinate speed equals the model coordinate root mean square displacement divided by the observation interval.
This quotient depends on the observation interval. It is not instantaneous physical velocity. At zero interval the quotient is undefined, even though the displacement is zero.
Model assumptions and every term’s meaning
- The same one-coordinate ideal Brownian model as the RMS relation.
- A positive observation interval is required for the quotient.
- Lines joining recorded points are a rendering convention, not a velocity measurement.
- Define the observable
- This defines an interval-dependent comparison. It does not introduce a physical instantaneous Brownian velocity. Read the prerequisite
- Apparent coordinate speed
- A distance-per-interval statistic. It is not a molecular collision speed. Read the prerequisite
- Divide by the same interval
- The distance grows as the square root of time, while the denominator grows linearly. The quotient therefore decreases as the interval grows. Read the prerequisite
- Model coordinate RMS
- The same accepted one-coordinate model displacement used by the neighboring RMS equation. Read the prerequisite
- Positive observation interval
- A zero interval yields no apparent-speed value. The interface keeps the explanation instead of fabricating zero or infinity. Read the prerequisite
Every term’s units were checked when this page was built. That checks the units, not the model. This equation is written for this edition in modern notation, not transcribed from the paper.
Explore the equation · Modern model notation
From spreading to a measurable distance
Shown in modern letters; Einstein's are in §4 of the German source face.
is the positive square root
Select a term or operation. In the formula, Down enters an operation, Up returns to its parent, and Left/Right move between siblings. Escape clears selection. Tab leaves the formula.
Each term and operation, in words
No live values
Symbolic here. Open the linked laboratory for a worked example and live values.
Read the equation aloud in words
The model coordinate root mean square displacement equals the square root of two times the diffusion coefficient times the observation interval.
Squaring measures spread without cancellation between directions. Taking the positive square root turns squared distance back into a distance. Four times the observation interval gives twice the model RMS, not four times.
Model assumptions and every term’s meaning
- Independent, zero-mean Gaussian displacement increments in a homogeneous liquid.
- One-coordinate model statistic, not a measured speed or a sample estimate.
- The overdamped regime is assumed rather than established from additional particle and fluid measurements.
- A model relation
- This equality concerns the ideal model. A finite synthetic ensemble fluctuates around it; its sample RMS is displayed separately. Read the prerequisite
- Coordinate RMS
- One coordinate, not the total three-dimensional distance. Model RMS and sample RMS have different meanings. Read the prerequisite
- Why a square root?
- Two D t has units of squared length. Its positive square root has units of length and defines the typical displacement. Read the prerequisite
- Build the mean square
- Independent zero-mean increments add their variances. The definition of D makes the coordinate mean square equal to 2 D t. Read the prerequisite
- Diffusion coefficient
- This is the accepted model diffusivity, not a rate inferred from the synthetic data. Read the prerequisite
- Observation interval
- This is the interval used for the displayed displacement, not the simulation frame rate. Re-observing the trial preserves its paths. Read the prerequisite
Every term’s units were checked when this page was built. That checks the units, not the model. This equation is written for this edition in modern notation, not transcribed from the paper.
Modern qualifications
The four numbers are this page’s own example. Einstein’s observable is the mean square of the displacement along one axis, ; its square root, , is the RMS used here.
Signed displacements can cancel. Their squares still record movement.
What this relies on
- All displacements use the same origin, axis, units and observation interval.
Assumptions and limits: Zero average is not no movement
Assumed here
- All displacements use the same origin, axis, units and observation interval.
What this does not establish
- The model expectation need not equal the mean of one small sample.
- Net displacement is not total path length.
Source context: Annalen der Physik (4), 17, 549–560 (1905), §§1–5. Bibliographic pointer; this preview is not a source transcription or translation.
