A derivation
Transform derivatives before naming fields
How do the field equations change coordinates?
The 6 printed paragraphs this passage explains
- §6, paragraph 1: Einstein assumes that the Maxwell-Hertz equations for empty space hold in the stationary system K, with X, Y, Z the electric force and L, M, N the magnetic force.
- §6, paragraph 2: Applying the transformation of section 3, he rewrites these equations in the coordinates and time of the moving system k.
- §6, paragraph 3: The principle of relativity requires that the same equations hold in k, for the electric and magnetic forces measured there by their effects on charges and magnets.
- §6, paragraph 4: Since the two sets of equations for k must say the same thing, the forces measured in k equal combinations of those in K, up to one common factor ψ(v) that may depend on the speed.
- §6, paragraph 5: Going to k and back, and symmetry, fix that factor at 1, which gives the transformation of the electric and magnetic forces. To say what it means, Einstein takes a unit charge at rest in one system or the other, and says the first three equations can be put into words in two ways.
- §6, footnote 1: A footnote gives the symmetry argument: with only one magnetic component present, reversing the direction of motion must reverse the sign of the transformed electric force without changing its size.
In the moving observer’s coordinates the derivatives in time and along mix. Grouping the result so that the Maxwell-Hertz equations keep their form points to the moving observer’s electric and magnetic components; the form alone does not prove that identification, which rests on the principle of relativity.
Partial by partial t equals gamma times, partial by partial t prime minus v partial by partial x prime. Partial by partial x equals gamma times, partial by partial x prime minus v over c squared partial by partial t prime.
Take the simplest case, a wave travelling along with an electric component and a magnetic component . In SI units and empty space the Maxwell-Hertz equations reduce to the pair and . Substitute the two derivative rules above into both equations; the next step needs the pair.
After the substitution, and appear only in the combinations and . Multiply each by and call the results and . The pair then reads and , the same form as before. The field-equations laboratory shows this grouping one term at a time.
The form alone would also allow every new field to carry one common factor that depends on , and the paper keeps such a factor at first. Transforming there and back must return the original fields, so the factor’s value at times its value at must be 1. By symmetry the factor cannot depend on the direction of motion, so it is the same at and , and the positive root makes it 1.
Open the foundation: Partial derivatives and held-fixed quantities
Show every step here: Transform derivatives before naming fields
Letters: the paper writes the electric force as (X, Y, Z) and the magnetic force as (L, M, N), in Gaussian units, with V for the speed of light and β for the modern γ; in k they are to . This explanation works in SI units, where the electric field is E, the magnetic field B, and a factor appears that Gaussian units hide. The primed coordinates and are the paper's ξ and τ.
- The paper begins with the Maxwell–Hertz equations for empty space, valid in K. One of them, in its letters, is , and there are six in all.
- To write them in k's coordinates, every derivative must be rewritten, since and each depend on both t and x: and .
- The chain rule: a change in t changes by γ and by −γv, so . A change in x changes by and by γ, so . Those are the two rules below.
Partial by partial t equals gamma times, partial by partial t prime minus v partial by partial x prime. Partial by partial x equals gamma times, partial by partial x prime minus v over c squared partial by partial t prime.
- Take the simplest case, a wave along x with an electric component and a magnetic component . In SI units and empty space the equations reduce to the pair and .
- Substitute into the first: . Cancel γ and move the terms to the left and the terms to the right: .
- Substitute into the second: . Collect the same way: .
- The fields now appear only in two combinations. Multiply both by γ and name them: and . The pair becomes and , the same form as in K.
- The paper does the same with all six equations and finds the combinations and in place of N and M. The principle of relativity requires that the Maxwell–Hertz equations hold in k too, for the forces the moving system defines by their pushes on electric and magnetic charges.
- So the paper sets each new force equal to the matching combination times one common factor ψ(v), which may depend on v but not on the coordinates. The form of the equations cannot fix that factor.
- Fixing it: transforming to k and back must give the original fields, so the factor's values at v and at −v multiply to 1. By symmetry, reversing v reverses the sign of a component such as without changing its size, so the factor is the same at v and −v; the positive root makes it 1 (p. 909).
- Worked: a wave running along +x has in SI. In a frame moving the same way at 0.6c, : the field halves, as the frequency will in §7.
- Keep two claims apart. That the equations keep their form after the substitution is algebra. That the new combinations are the fields the moving observer measures is the principle of relativity, applied to forces on charges at rest in k.
- Changing from the paper's Gaussian units to SI is a change of units, done term by term, not a renaming of letters.
Explore the equations in this step
Read each operation, check its units and assumptions, or open the mathematical step behind it. These are modern teaching equations, not the equations as printed.
Explore the equation · Modern model notationEinstein's letters
The time derivative, rewritten
The derivative with respect to is times the derivative with respect to minus times the derivative with respect to .
The derivative with respect to is times the derivative with respect to minus times the derivative with respect to .
Select a term or operation. In the formula, Down enters an operation, Up returns to its parent, and Left/Right move between siblings. Escape clears selection. Tab leaves the formula.
Each term and operation, in words
No live values
This equation states a relation. No instrument on this page computes its terms.
Read the equation aloud in words
The time derivative is gamma times the primed time derivative minus v times the primed x derivative.
The rate of change with stationary time, written through the moving system's derivatives. Per second on both sides.
Model assumptions and every term’s meaning
- The moving system moves along x at speed v relative to the stationary system, with |v| < c. Modern teaching notation: gamma is the paper's beta, c its V.
- Partial derivatives of a field, taken in each system's own coordinates; the chain rule through the Lorentz transformation relates them.
- The two together
- The chain rule: a change in one stationary coordinate moves both moving coordinates. Read the prerequisite
- The matching rate in the moving system
- The same kind of derivative, in the moving system's coordinates. Read the prerequisite
- Rate of change in the stationary system
- How a field changes with this stationary-system coordinate, the others held fixed. Read the prerequisite
- What it asserts
- An identity between operators: it holds for any field it is applied to. Substituted into both of Maxwell's equations for a plane wave, it regroups them into the same equations for the primed fields. Read the prerequisite
- Times gamma
- The same factor as the transformation itself. Read the prerequisite
- The other rate in the moving system
- Because each moving coordinate depends on both x and t, the other derivative enters too. Read the prerequisite
- Times v
- How strongly the other coordinate enters. Read the prerequisite
- Lorentz factor
- One over the square root of one minus v squared over c squared. At 0.6c it is 1.25. Read the prerequisite
- Time, moving system
- t′: the moving system's time. Read the prerequisite
- Time, stationary system
- t: the derivative is taken as t varies. Read the prerequisite
- Position, moving system
- x′: the moving system's position. Read the prerequisite
- Speed of the moving system
- Along x. Its sign gives the direction. Read the prerequisite
Every term’s units were checked when this page was built. That checks the units, not the model. This equation is written for this edition in modern notation, not transcribed from the paper.
Explore the equation · Modern model notationEinstein's letters
The x derivative, rewritten
The derivative with respect to is times the derivative with respect to minus times the derivative with respect to over squared.
The derivative with respect to is times the derivative with respect to minus times the derivative with respect to over squared.
Select a term or operation. In the formula, Down enters an operation, Up returns to its parent, and Left/Right move between siblings. Escape clears selection. Tab leaves the formula.
Each term and operation, in words
No live values
This equation states a relation. No instrument on this page computes its terms.
Read the equation aloud in words
The x derivative is gamma times the primed x derivative minus v over c squared times the primed time derivative.
The rate of change along x, written through the moving system's derivatives. Per metre on both sides.
Model assumptions and every term’s meaning
- The moving system moves along x at speed v relative to the stationary system, with |v| < c. Modern teaching notation: gamma is the paper's beta, c its V.
- Partial derivatives of a field, taken in each system's own coordinates; the chain rule through the Lorentz transformation relates them.
- The two together
- The chain rule: a change in one stationary coordinate moves both moving coordinates. Read the prerequisite
- The matching rate in the moving system
- The same kind of derivative, in the moving system's coordinates. Read the prerequisite
- Rate of change in the stationary system
- How a field changes with this stationary-system coordinate, the others held fixed. Read the prerequisite
- c squared
- The square of the speed of light. Read the prerequisite
- Over c squared
- Keeps the units: per metre, like the left side. Read the prerequisite
- What it asserts
- An identity between operators: it holds for any field it is applied to. Substituted into both of Maxwell's equations for a plane wave, it regroups them into the same equations for the primed fields. Read the prerequisite
- Times gamma
- The same factor as the transformation itself. Read the prerequisite
- The other rate in the moving system
- Because each moving coordinate depends on both x and t, the other derivative enters too. Read the prerequisite
- Times v
- How strongly the other coordinate enters. Read the prerequisite
- Lorentz factor
- One over the square root of one minus v squared over c squared. At 0.6c it is 1.25. Read the prerequisite
- Position, moving system
- x′: the moving system's position. Read the prerequisite
- Position, stationary system
- x: the derivative is taken as x varies. Read the prerequisite
- Speed of light
- The paper's V. Read the prerequisite
- Time, moving system
- t′: the moving system's time. Read the prerequisite
- Speed of the moving system
- Along x. Its sign gives the direction. Read the prerequisite
Every term’s units were checked when this page was built. That checks the units, not the model. This equation is written for this edition in modern notation, not transcribed from the paper.
Modern qualifications
Einstein writes the electric force as and the magnetic force as , in Gaussian units, with for the speed of light; his is the modern , not . The field tensor that packs all six components together came later, with Minkowski in 1908. Where this edition uses it, it checks results; it is never a step in the 1905 argument.
In the moving observer’s coordinates the derivatives in time and along x mix. Grouping the result so that the Maxwell-Hertz equations keep their form points to the moving observer’s electric and magnetic components; the form alone does not prove that identification, which rests on the principle of relativity.
What this relies on
- The coordinates transform by the Lorentz map, and the fields obey Maxwell’s equations in empty space.
- The example is in SI units, so factors of c appear explicitly.
Assumptions and limits: Transform derivatives before naming fields
Assumed here
- The coordinates transform by the Lorentz map, and the fields obey Maxwell’s equations in empty space.
- The example is in SI units, so factors of c appear explicitly.
What this does not establish
- Einstein’s Gaussian equations become SI ones by a change of units, not by renaming symbols.
- A common factor on all the new fields is fixed by a separate argument, going there and back and the symmetry of space; rearranging the equations does not fix it.
Earlier step: Light constraints leave a scale to determineThe sideways step needs its own condition
Source context: German source · English · Interlinear gloss · Facsimile